Meal Delivery Comparison
Dinnerly vs Purple Carrot: Full Comparison
Budget-friendly meal kits with simpler recipes and fewer ingredients vs Plant-based meal kits with creative vegan and vegetarian recipes
Quick Answer
Dinnerly offers meal kit starting at ~$5/meal, best for budget-conscious households wanting simple, affordable meals. Purple Carrot offers meal kit starting at ~$10/meal, best for plant-based eaters wanting creative vegan and vegetarian recipes.
When comparing Dinnerly and Purple Carrot, the key difference comes down to their approach: Dinnerly is a meal kit service starting at ~$5/meal, while Purple Carrot is a meal kit service starting at ~$10/meal.
Dinnerly is best for budget-conscious households wanting simple, affordable meals. Purple Carrot is best for plant-based eaters wanting creative vegan and vegetarian recipes.
In this detailed comparison, we break down pricing, meal variety, dietary options, preparation requirements, and overall value so you can choose the right service for your needs.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Dinnerly | Purple Carrot |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Meal Kit | Meal Kit |
| Starting Price | ~$5/meal | ~$10/meal |
| Min. Meals/Week | 3 | 2 |
| Prep Time | 20-30 min | 25-40 min |
| Best For | Budget-conscious households wanting simple, affordable meals | Plant-based eaters wanting creative vegan and vegetarian recipes |
| Dietary Options | Vegetarian, Healthy | Vegetarian, Vegan, Gluten-Free |
| Shipping | Free shipping | Free shipping |
| Meal Variety | 20+ recipes weekly | 16+ plant-based recipes weekly |
Key Differences
The biggest difference between Dinnerly and Purple Carrot is their service model. Dinnerly delivers meal kit at ~$5/meal per serving, requiring 20-30 min of preparation. Purple Carrot delivers meal kit at ~$10/meal per serving, requiring 25-40 min of preparation.
If you enjoy cooking and want to develop culinary skills, the meal kit format from Dinnerly may be the better choice. If your priority is time savings and convenience, the Purple Carrot prepared meal option is hard to beat.
Dietary options also differ: Dinnerly offers Vegetarian, Healthy, while Purple Carrot offers Vegetarian, Vegan, Gluten-Free.
Dinnerly Pros & Cons
Pros
- Lowest-priced meal kit
- Simple recipes (6 steps or fewer)
- Fewer ingredients per recipe
- Digital recipe cards
Cons
- Requires active cooking time
- Minimum 3 meals per week
Purple Carrot Pros & Cons
Pros
- 100% plant-based
- Creative vegan recipes
- Global flavor profiles
- High-protein options
Cons
- Requires active cooking time
- Minimum 2 meals per week
Price Comparison
On price, Purple Carrot is more affordable at ~$10/meal per meal, compared to ~$5/meal for Dinnerly. Both services offer free shipping and flexible weekly ordering with no long-term commitment.
Keep in mind that prices vary based on the number of meals per week you select. Ordering more meals per week typically reduces the per-meal price for both services.
Which Should You Choose?
Dinnerly is ideal for budget-conscious households wanting simple, affordable meals. The service offers lowest-priced meal kit, simple recipes (6 steps or fewer), fewer ingredients per recipe, digital recipe cards, making it a strong choice if these features align with your priorities.
Purple Carrot is ideal for plant-based eaters wanting creative vegan and vegetarian recipes. The service offers 100% plant-based, creative vegan recipes, global flavor profiles, high-protein options, making it the better choice if these features matter more to you.
Both services allow you to pause or skip weeks, and you can cancel at any time without penalty.
Ask Supper AI for meal ideas
Get personalized recipe suggestions, substitutions, and cooking tips from our AI-powered chef assistant.
Try Supper AI